BAKEWARE REVIEWS / Pie

How to Choose Pie

Choose by material, size, release and budget.

Updated 2026-11-02About 3 minLocal test
Affiliate disclosure: this page may contain affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. Placeholder tracking parameters must be replaced with an approved affiliate ID before launch.
Quick answer

Choose by material, size, release and budget. Pie plates depend on diameter/depth/material/rim.

Why it matters

Diameter.

Step by step

  1. Check material/size/release/budget/wash.
  2. Separate sheet/cake/muffin/pie.
  3. Compare heat/coating/thickness/durability.
  4. Check 2-3 brands; confirm size/returns.

Common mistakes

  • Looks only, not material/size.
  • Ignoring heat/coating/release.
  • Wrong size/leaks.
  • Not checking size/returns.

Checklist

  • Material/size/release/budget/wash.
  • Sheet/cake/muffin/pie.
  • Heat/coating/thickness/durability.
  • Size/returns/support.
  • Budget/care/storage.

Who it is for

If this is your first Pie, narrow by Diameter. and Depth. first, then look at specific models.

Key facts

  • Diameter.
  • Depth.
  • Material.

FAQ

How to Choose Pie

Choose by material, size, release and budget. Pie plates depend on diameter/depth/material/rim.

What should I check before buying a Pie?

Pie plates depend on diameter/depth/material/rim. Key checks: Diameter.; Depth..

Is a Pie worth it?

Depends on use, budget and upkeep; a Pie is not automatically better because it costs more.

Source: FTC

Top picks

ProductBest forPrice
PyrexGlass/budgetLow-midSee buying guide
Nordic WareCake/classicMidSee buying guide
Williams SonomaSets/giftsHighSee buying guide